Craving Edible Clays: Anemia or Androgens
Author(s) : Odimegwu JI 1 , Jane-Sharon EE 1 , Nkemehule FE 1 , Okunnuga J 1 , Buhari AO 1 , Okwuegbuna SN 1 and Duru Chidinma R 2
1 Department of Pharmacognosy , University of Lagos , Nigeria
2 Department of Pharmacognosy , University of Nigeria Teaching Hospital Enugu , Nigeria
Glob J Chem Sci
Article Type : Research Article
Figure 1: A; White clay B; Grey clay.
The study area;
Lagos, is the largest city in
the Nigerian state of the same name as well as in Nigeria and Sub-Saharan Africa. It is one of the
fastest-growing cities in the world [9-12] and one of the
most populous urban areas.
It is inhabited by people from diverse ethnic groups; Igbos, Yoruba's and
Hausas.
Kaolin is
distinguished from other industrial clays based on its fine particle size and
pure coloring [3]. It is consumed by many people in the African
continent and particularly in Nigeria [6]the behavior/habit of
eating soil is known as geophagia and usually classified as pica. Pica is the
craving and purposive consumption of substances not culturally defined as food [3]. It is also
defined as a psychological eating disorder shown by continuous consumption of largely non-nutritive
substances, such as ice (pagophagia);
hair (trichophagia);
paper (xylophagic) or soil, (geophagia) [4,13].
Geophagia is global though most common with people of African descent [14 ,15] whether living at home in Africa or abroad and can have serious negative effects on the health [6]. The consumption has been linked to the low educational background but the opposite is true for Nigeria where most of the sampling was carried out though some respondents lived abroad. Geophagia cuts across social strata and age, men and women purchase the clays from markets (Figure 2) or supermarkets and consume them , educated people and not so educated also do this. It seems to be a habit gets passed down from parents to offspring's or from friends to friends so it has a very social dimension.
Figure 2: Edible white clay on display at a local market. (Arrow on displayed clays).
There is a
compulsion to the behavior that defies reason as the materials being craved
are dirt. It is endemic in different communities in the world though it is
observed typically but not surprisingly at pregnancy [16,17]
and because expectant women crave all sorts of
things and locally believed to be as a result of anaemia and nausea associated
with early trimesters of pregnancy but recent surveys have shown that
non-expectant women and children also crave clays [16-19].
The root cause
for soil craving has not been well described in the past and we deemed it
necessary to know why these minerals, in particular are craved instead of
assuming it has the same roots as other pica habits. We surveyed with specific
questions to reveal the sometimes hidden reasons for the compulsion.
This research aims to chemically evaluate clay mined in Nigeria for their chemical contents and find out through semi-structured questionnaires, the reasons for raw clay consumption and possible craving. Our sample area was mushin and surulere local government areas in Lagos State, Nigeria. This area is in the Western part of Nigeria but is mostly cosmopolitan populated by people from all over Nigeria. The local names of edible clays are Igbo; Nzu, Hausa; Farar kasa, Benin; Eko and Efik/Ibibios; Ndom (Figure 3 and 4).
Figure 3: Map of Mushin and Surulere study areas of ethno-survey.
Figure 4: Map of Nigeria showing the distribution of raw clay [20].
Materials
The clay samples
were bought from Mushin market located at 6°32?N 3°21?E Lagos, Nigeria in July
2019.
Beakers, test
tube , test tube rack, conical flask, spatula, funnel, measuring cylinder, paper
tapes, atomic absorption spectrophotometer (Thermo scientific, Series model
2004), oven, Kjeldahl digestion apparatus, Agilent cary 630, Analytical
weighing balance, crucibles, electrical furnace, desiccator.
Methodology
Reagents: Absolute ethanol, Methanol,
Chloroform, Fehling A and B, Hydrochloric acid, Distilled water.
Ethno-survey
A survey of clay
consumption was carried out within Mushin and Surulere local governments in
Lagos State, Nigeria. 850 respondents were given questionnaires (Appendix 1)
and they responded and returned the papers. The study population was among
adolescents and adults in Lagos state on their knowledge and consumption habit
of clay. Data was collected from the study population and analyzed accordingly.
Determination of the mineral contents using
AAS spectroscopy
The method
described by (Association of Official Analytical Chemists, 2005) was adopted.
Calcium, potassium, sodium, magnesium iron, cadmium, lead, were analyzed from
the triple acid digestion (wet digestion method). The concentration of metal is
detected in mg/litre or ppm. The metal mg/100g= (Concentration of metal in
ppm/weight of sample).
Phytochemical assays
Phytochemical
analysis was conducted on clay samples according to [8]
using
a modified analytical method.
Fourier Transformer Infra-Red Spectroscopy analysis
The procedure
used for FTIR spectroscopy analysis is that mentioned by Galindo and Viseras
[7].
Proximate analysis
Determination
of moisture content
The method described by (Association
of Official Analytical chemist, 2005) was adopted.
Ash
content
The
procedure uses a high-temperature muffle furnace capable of maintaining the
temperature between 500°C and 600°C. Water and other volatile materials are
vaporized and organic substances are burnt in the presence of oxygen to give CO2,
H2O and NO2. The ash content is determined by the
ignition of a known weight of food sample at 550°C until all carbon has been
removed. The residue is the ash which is taken to represent the inorganic
constituents of the food.
Determination
of Nitrogen and crude protein
The
micro Kjeldahl method as described by (Association of Official Analytical
chemist, 2005) was used.
Carbohydrate
determination (Anthrone method)
1g of
sample was weighed into a mortar, homogenized with 10ml 2.5% H2SO4,
poured into a boiling tube and heated for 15 minutes at 100°C. The boiled
mixture was allowed to cool and then filtered. Next, the filtrate was made up
to 250ml with distilled water. 10 ml was taken from the 250 ml and diluted to
100 ml with distilled water. Then, 1 ml was taken from the 100 ml into a clean
boiling tube, 4 ml of Anthrone reagent (0.1g Anthrone powder dissolved in 100 ml
concentrated sulphuric acid) was added and the reaction mixture was boiled for
10 minutes at 100°C. It was then cooled and the absorbance was recorded at
620nm wavelength. Glucose standard was also prepared by dissolving 0.1g
D-glucose in 100 ml distilled water (i.e. 100 mg/100 ml glucose solution). 10 ml
was taken from the 100 L of glucose solution and it was diluted to 100 ml with
distilled water. Next, a serial dilution of glucose standard was prepared, 4 ml
Anthrone reagent was added to it, boiled for 10 minutes and absorbance was read
at 620 nm wavelength.
Gas
chromatography analysis
The
sample to be tested was prepared by adding 10 mg of white and grey clay
previously dissolved in 5 ml of water separately. GC analysis was then
conducted on the samples using an aliquot of the sample, which was injected
into the column and allowed to run for about an hour.
Gas
chromatography/Mass spectrometry
Each kaolin sample was extracted for the analysis by accurately weighing the test sample into a conical flask; n-Hexane and Dichloro-ethane were used for the derivatization. The mixture was filtered using Whatman-42 filter paper. The filtrate was taken through column chromatography in a glass column packed with pre-heated/cooled silica gel as its stationary phase while n-Hexane was the mobile phase. (The silica gel was pre-activated in an oven at 103°C for 2 hours). Anhydrous Sodium sulphate was added to absorb any available moisture in the system. The resulting evaluate from the chromatographic column was concentrated to about 2 ml in the fume cupboard and stored in a glass vial for subsequent injection into the Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometer. Agilent 7820 Å Gas chromatograph coupled to a 5977E Mass spectrometer was used in analyzing the sample for about 30 minutes.
Hematology
20 female Wister rats randomly distributed into 4 groups were used for these studies. They were housed in the animal house of the college of Medicine campus following stipulated ethical procedures for animal studies (Approval: CMUL/HREC/0728/19). Animals were fed and observed for a period of 28 days, the blood sample was randomly collected from 5 animals for hematology before the first treatment with the test sample, then after 14 days of treatment with the test drug and lastly on the 28th day of treatment with the test drug (Table 1).
Groups |
Amount of edible clay fed
the animal |
Control |
Water |
Low Dose |
250 mg/kg |
Medium Dose |
500 mg/kg |
High
Dose |
1000 mg/kg |
Table 1: Treatment Plan
Acute
toxicity
A total of six albino mice were used for the studies, Test drug; 1 g of kaolin powder was weighed and mixed in 5 ml of purified water was administered orally to the animals and they were observed for 72 hrs.
Result
Variables (Age Years) |
Frequency(N=850) |
Percentage% |
13-20 |
128 |
15.1 |
21-40 |
482 |
56.7 |
41-60 |
204 |
24 |
>60 |
36 |
4.2 |
Table 2: Socio-demographic data of respondents in ethno-survey of edible clay consumption in Nigeria.
The ethno-surveys showed that 574 (67.5%) of the respondents know white clay and 493 (58.0%) know grey clay while 276 (32.5%) do not know white and grey clay. The level of knowledge of clay and its consumption result showed that 445 (52.4%) respondents had eaten either white or grey clay while 405 (47.6%) have not. More respondents had eaten clay as teenagers 215 (25.3%) than as adults 58 (6.8%). Respondents who felt the need to eat clay were 390 (45.9%), This is significant as they experienced an urge to eat it though 405 (47.6%) says it is not applicable which could be out of natural reticence or not been willing to real craving dirt. This is based on information during an oral interview where the respondent was ashamed to let her family know that she craves and eats clay. 55 (6.5%) did not feel a need while did not have a response which could be that they may be embarrassed about the habit. Some respondents, Table 3, 149 (17.5%) like the taste of clay, 91 (10.7%) liked the odour, 138 (16.2%) ate clay because their friends ate it while 67 (7.9%) cannot seem to help themselves while 405 (47.6%) had no response (Tables 2-4).
Variables |
Frequency
(N=850) |
Percentage
% |
Do you
know white clays? |
|
|
Yes |
574 |
67.5 |
No |
276 |
32.5 |
Do you
know grey clays? |
|
|
Yes |
493 |
58 |
No |
357 |
42 |
Have
you ever eaten white or grey clays? |
|
|
Yes |
445 |
52.4 |
No |
405 |
47.6 |
When
did you first eat clay? |
|
|
As a
child |
172 |
20.2 |
Teenager |
215 |
25.3 |
Adult |
58 |
6.8 |
Not
applicable |
405 |
47.6 |
Do you
know other people who eat clay? |
|
|
Yes |
390 |
45.9 |
No |
55 |
6.5 |
Not
applicable |
405 |
47.6 |
Do you
feel a particular need to eat clay? |
|
|
Yes |
224 |
26.4 |
No |
221 |
26 |
Not
applicable |
405 |
47.6 |
Can you
get clay easily? |
|
|
Yes |
300 |
35.3 |
No |
144 |
16.9 |
Not
applicable |
406 |
47.8 |
Table 3: Knowledge of edible clay and behaviors.
Variables |
Frequency (N=850) |
Percentage % |
Why do you eat clay? |
|
|
I like the taste |
149 |
17.5 |
I like the odour |
91 |
10.7 |
My friends were
eating it |
138 |
16.2 |
I can’t seem to
help myself |
67 |
7.9 |
Not applicable |
405 |
47.6 |
Is there a
particular time you eat clay? |
|
|
Morning |
18 |
2.1 |
Afternoon |
47 |
5.5 |
Evening /Night |
55 |
6.5 |
Any time |
325 |
38.2 |
Not applicable |
405 |
47.6 |
Do you feel any
discomfort after eating clay? |
|
|
Yes |
148 |
17.4 |
No |
297 |
35 |
Not applicable |
405 |
47.6 |
What kind of
discomfort? |
|
|
Stomach pain |
42 |
4.9 |
Constipation |
76 |
8.9 |
Diarrhoea |
10 |
1.2 |
Bloating |
20 |
2.4 |
Not applicable |
702 |
82.6 |
Table 4: Knowledge of effects of consuming clay.
The silicon content in white clay is greater than that of grey clay figure 5A. Aluminum, potassium, sodium and magnesium were all present in both clays. There is very little iron recorded. Proximate analysis data shows that white clay has the highest ash content (94.83%) (Figure 5A-C and 6-9).
Figure 5A-C: A; Metals in clay samples measured in weight PPM from AAS analysis. B; Heavy metals as found in grey and white clay from AAS analysis (PPM) C. Constituents of grey and white clay from proximate analysis.
FTIR Assay
Figure 6A-B: A; FTIR interferogram of gray clay B; FTIR interferogram of white clay.
Figure 7: Organic compounds present in white and grey clay from GC analysis.
Figure 8: GC Chromatogram for grey clay.
Figure 9: GC Chromatogram for
white clay.
Figures 10A-B: A; Effects of different concentration of white clay on blood lymphocytes of Wistar rats B; Effects of different concentration of clay in the Hemoglobin.
Figure 11A-D: A; Chromatogram of Indomethacin in grey kaolin. B; Chromatogram of beta Carotene in grey kaolin C; Chromatogram of Cholestan-6-en-3-ol in grey kaolin D; Chromatogram of Pregna-2,4-dien-20-one in grey kaolin.
Figure 12A-B:
Chromatogram of Vanillin in white kaolin B. Chromatogram of cyclopentane acetic
acid in white kaolin.
The
knowledge of health benefits and side effects derived from clay showed that 226
(22.6%) of respondents felt white clays are useful for health, 219 (25.8%)
Table 4, felt it was not useful to health. Respondents who noticed side effects
of clay were 263 (30.9%), 182 (21.4%) who did not notice any side effect of
clay, most respondents 405 (47.6%) did not get any response. The belief of side
effects of anaemia occurred in 158 respondents, constipation in 79 respondents,
and cancer in 29 respondents. However, 587 had no response. Respondents who had
stomach discomforts were 42 (4.9%), 76(8.9%) had constipation, 10 (1.2%) had diarrhea,
20 (2.4%) had bloating while 702 (82.6%) had no discomfort. The understanding
was that women ate clay more than men [21-23] and the results collected from
the survey seems to point that way 62% of respondents are female who ate clay. (Figures 11 A-D, Figures 12 A-B).
Female
respondents showed that 98 (11.5%) women eat clay while pregnant, 133 (15.6%)
do not eat clay while pregnant while 619 (72.8%) do not fit into the category.
Amongst the women who eat clay while pregnant 24 (2.8%) eat clay because it
prevents nausea, 33 (3.9%) eat clay because it helps the child and they feel
like eating it while 8 (0.9%) had no reason. Association between respondent’s
knowledge of white clay and side effects of clay shows that there’s a
significant association between respondent’s knowledge of white clay and their
side effects with a p-value < 0.05 indicating significance. The strength of
FTIR applied to clay mineralogy lies in its ability to characterize the
functional group and fingerprint regions of very small quantities of samples (Figures 6A and B) [17].
Proximate
analysis data shows that white clay has the highest ash content (94.83%) (Figures 5A-C), generally, high ash
content is an indication that the compound contains abundant mineral content.
The moisture content was lower when compared to grey clay suggestive that low
moisture content is desirable as it discourages growth of bacteria and mould, which
decreases instability and increase shelf storage capacity [14]. Previous
studies [15] on geophagia found out that glucose levels were much greater in
mice in the clay stationary groups compared to rotated mice and “No clay”
controls. This may indicate the presence of a carbon source in the clay
samples, which might explain the euphoria and satisfaction felt after
consumption by people practicing clay geophagia however this data cannot be
fully supported from the result established above.
The
crude protein present in the sample is too minute to make a significant
contribution to dietary consumption. Elemental analysis data carried out on the
samples using AAS showed that white clay contains 0.149 ppm of Lead (Pb) which
compared to the standard set by Kariuki et al [18] is 0.2, 0.1 and 0.3 ppm
respectively for Pb, Cd and Hg. The value of lead in clay is below accepted
limits. However suggested maximum value of lead consumption is 0.01 ppm or 3
mg/week [19] Grey clays had no trace of lead which typically targets multiple
organs in the body due to its systemic toxicity causing cardiovascular, renal,
gastrointestinal and hematological effects [21].
White
and grey clays contained 0.101ppm and 0.631ppm of mercury respectively. The
value of grey clay is above the standard limit, it has been established that
consumption of mercury may lead to kidney damage [22]. They also contained
0.458 and 0.289 ppm of cadmium respectively. White clay had above the limit
compared to the standard which is 0.1ppm.
However,
The Joint FAO/WHO had recommended a 0.007 mg/kg bodyweight limit for cadmium.
Elevated concentrations of Cadmium in foodstuffs have been associated with
kidney disorders [15]. Arsenic present are 1.191ppm and 0.092 ppm in white and grey clay respectively.
Chronic oral exposure of humans to inorganic arsenic at doses as low as
0.05-0.1 mg/kg/day is frequently associated with neurological or hematological
toxicity [15] .The safety limit of arsenic in soil ranges 5-20 ppm that will
not have harmful effects for a long time [23]. Arsenic at over 0.01 ppm is
toxic [24]. Huge soil consumption could lead to severe vomiting, disturbances
in blood circulation, damage to the nervous system and eventually death [21].
Magnesium was 31.86 and 31.01 ppm, Potassium, 74.66 ppm and 71.49 ppm and
Sodium 43.37 ppm and 41.34 ppm in white clay and grey clays. Geophagious
ingestion of these clay minerals could cause Potassium absorption increase due
to altered cat ion exchange capacity, in a biological system; potassium is
required in the amount of 4700 mg/day [25]. The level of potassium in the
samples can cause a deleterious effect depending on the level of consumption.
Iron
present in the clays was 2.364 ppm and 1.39 ppm respectively in white and grey.
Recommended daily value for iron is 8 mg/day, furthermore, the safety limit of
iron intake suggests a maximum of 45 mg/day. Several studies about clay
consumption depicted iron deficiency leading to anaemia. This can be easily
inferred that Iron mal-absorption is very common due to the ion exchange
capacity of the soil and contaminants [26] but our results (Figures 10 A &
B) show iron present in the samples was high which suggest its abundance in
clay. There were noticeably high levels of potassium and iron in geophagia
clayey samples can result in anaemia among pregnant women and children [15].
The Aluminum content was 62.7 ppm and 59.7 ppm and Silicon was 83.0 ppm and
13.0 ppm white and grey clays respectively. Aluminum content is higher in grey
than in white clay.
Phytochemical
analysis carried out on the clay samples showed that the samples did not
contain tannins, saponins, flavonoids, cardiac glycosides, alkaloids, steroids
or reducing sugar. This is different from a 2017 finding who reported presence
of reducing sugars and steroidal nucleus in grey clay. However, a test for
anthraquinone was positive in white clay but not in the grey clays.
To
eliminate the uncertainty of minerals identification based on functional
grouping FTIR spectrophotometry was used. The IR bands representing the
Kaolinite hydroxyls for white and grey kaolin have been experimentally observed
as 3533 cm-1, 3373 cm-1, 3686 cm-1, 3645 cm-1,
3615 cm-1 and 3432 cm-1. The OH, deformation bands were
observed at 913 and 909 cm-1. Bands associated with SiO stretching
were 793 cm-1, 797 cm-1, 749 cm-1 and 691 cm-1,
whereas SiO deformation bands were 1099 cm-1 and 1114 cm-1.
Peaks for theoretical kaolinite, defined as pure kaolinite with the chemical
formula Al2Si2O5(OH)4, are also
given. Other peaks corresponding to smectites, muscovite and quartz were
equally observed.
Kaolinite
has an absorption band between 3500cm-1 and 3700 cm-1
corresponding to the stretching frequency of the OH group. When the four
characteristic bands (3700 cm-1, 3760 cm-1, 3650 cm-1
and 3620 cm-1) are well defined, the structure of kaolin is ordered.
When the band at 3670 cm-1 disappears, the kaolinite structure is
disordered and easier to dehydrate [27].
Peak
values obtained for the highest frequencies observed in the kaolinite samples
were the stretching OH vibrations occurring for these samples between 3620 cm-1
to 3697 cm-1, but only white kaolin exhibited a peak at 3432 cm-1
which is suggestive of mica. There was no interference of peaks occurring at
these highest frequencies where stretching the OH vibrations occur in white and
grey kaolin similar to the observations of [22]. Interferences of peaks were
however observed at lower frequencies (between 111 cm-1 - 500 cm-1)
of bending vibrations [27]. Within this
range of wavelength, main functional groups were SiO and Al-OH. The Al-OH
absorption peak was identified for grey kaolin and white kaolin at 909 cm-1 for theoretical kaolinite
it is at 919 cm-1, 909 cm-1. Possible peak interferences
of quartz in the region of 697cm-1; smectites at 797cm-1
and muscovite at 749 cm-1 for white and grey kaolin could only be
inferred.
*Corresponding Author: Duru Chidinma R, University of Nigeria Teaching Hospital, Enugu, Nigeria
Copyright: © 2021 All copyrights
are reserved by Duru Chidinma R, published by Coalesce Research Group. This This work is
licensed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which
permits unrestricted use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided
the original author and source are credited.